assessments

In the Arabian Sea, Competing Ports in Iran and Pakistan Fuel Ambition and Mistrust

7 MINS READJun 10, 2019 | 10:00 GMT
The Chinese-funded Pakistani port of Gwadar is slated to become the largest shipping port of South Asia by 2022.
(CHRISTINE-FELICE ROHRS/Getty Images)

The Pakistani port of Gwadar is located in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, which serves as a vital branch of China's massive Belt and Road Initiative.

Highlights
  • China’s expansion across South Asia and the Indian Ocean under its Belt and Road Initiative will drive India’s own regional outreach, heightening the importance of New Delhi's infrastructure projects such as the Chabahar port in Iran.
  • However, the threat of U.S. sanctions and the war in Afghanistan risk thwarting Indo-Iranian cooperation on the port project.
  • Meanwhile, China's closer ties with Pakistan means its own port project in Gwadar is more assured.

Editor's Note: This assessment is part of a series of analyses supporting Stratfor's upcoming 2019 Third-Quarter Forecast. These assessments are designed to provide more context and in-depth analysis of key developments over the next quarter.

On the eastern edge of the Arabian Sea, a pair of ports located just 160 kilometers apart (roughly 100 miles) lies at the heart of a multifaceted struggle for power among regional heavyweights in South Asia. For India, the Chinese-funded Gwadar port in Pakistan has heightened its concerns of encirclement under China’s Belt and Road Initiative. This has fueled New Delhi to secure its own infrastructure projects across the Indian Ocean, including Iran’s Chabahar port. Meanwhile, for Pakistan, India's growing presence in nearby Iran feeds into its own concerns of encirclement.

Iran — which counts India, Pakistan and China as partners — recently floated the idea of linking the two ports. However, such a juncture is highly unlikely because of these vying global strategies. The grandiose visions of spurring greater economic prosperity will instead continue to propel the two ports' development for years to come, even as both projects face key obstacles toward realizing their potential.

The Big Picture

The Iranian port of Chabahar and the Pakistani port of Gwadar fit into various overlapping dynamics shaping the geopolitics of South Asia. India and Pakistan, the subcontinent's enduring rivals, view the ports through the lens of encirclement. For Asian military rivals India and China, the ports fit into their plans of forging ambitious trade corridors across the region. And for Iran, the ports fit into its own balancing act between India and Pakistan.

India Bets on Iran's Port of Chabahar

India’s involvement in Chabahar has been central to the port's development, which lies on the coast of Iran’s Sistan-Baluchistan province near the Pakistan border. Iran and India first discussed cooperating on the development project in 2003, though it wasn't until the United States lifted sanctions against Iran in 2015 that the two countries began placing their words into action. In 2016, India pledged to invest $500 million in the port's development, before going on to sign an 18-month deal to take over operations of the port in December.

Iran's Motives. The port is currently able to process 8.5 million tons of cargo annually, which Iran's development plan sets out to increase tenfold by 2024, in addition to making it a deepwater facility. In doing so, Iran hopes that the port will lessen its reliance on the busy Bandar Abbas port, which lies inside the Strait of Hormuz and lacks a deepwater facility — forcing larger ships to first offload cargo to smaller ships in the Emirati port of Jebel Ali. Iran also sees Chabahar as a global access point by linking Indian Ocean traffic to the markets of Central Asia, Russia and Europe via the proposed International North-South Transport Corridor.

India's Motives. India, for its part, counts Iran as a key oil supplier and partner in the Middle East. (Renewed U.S. sanctions, however, have forced India to halt its Iranian oil purchases.) If completed, Chabahar would allow India to access what it sees as untapped export markets and energy reserves in Central Asia by building a trade route that runs directly from Iran to Afghanistan — thereby circumventing its archrival Pakistan. The port also fits into India’s wider efforts to expand its relationships with countries in Southeast Asia, East Africa and the Middle East in an effort to counter China's global expansion.

Potential Hitches. The United States' renewed sanctions push against Iran, however, risks stalling progress on Chabahar. U.S. sanctions have so far spared the project since the port supports Washington's core interest in boosting the region’s trade with Afghanistan. But the fear of potentially coming under the United States' financial wrath has nonetheless left India with room for pause. India, in fact, withdrew a tender this month seeking a partner firm for the project due to a lack of clarity on U.S. sanctions. The war in Afghanistan is another factor that can further thwart development plans, as any prospects of building trade corridors through Afghanistan en route to Central Asia will largely depend on resolving the conflict in the country.

A map showing the location of the Chabahar port in Iran and the Gwadar port in Pakistan.

While China Bets on Pakistan's Port of Gwadar

Gwadar, meanwhile, is located in Pakistan’s vast southwestern province of Balochistan, which borders Iran and Afghanistan. Featuring three multipurpose berths, the port can currently process about 30 million tons of cargo annually. But China and Pakistan's new development plan aims to increase this amount to 400 million tons, once the third phase of the port is complete in 2045. A Chinese state-owned firm first took over management on a 43-year lease in 2013. Two years later, Beijing then lavished Islamabad with $46 billion worth of China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) deals, drawing Gwadar under the umbrella of the Belt and Road Initiative. Then in 2017, Pakistan awarded a Chinese state-owned company a 40-year lease over the port.

Pakistan's Motives. Pakistan sees the Gwadar port as vital to its transformation from a developing economy into a thriving transit hub on the Arabian Sea — serving, in essence, as its gateway to the world. A bigger and better Gwadar would also allow Pakistan to diversify beyond its ports of Karachi and Qasim, whose upstream locations hinder Islamabad's ability to expand in order to meet increasing trade demands.

China's Motives. For China, which borders northern Pakistan and is the country’s strongest ally, the Gwadar port marks the western terminus of its multibillion-dollar CPEC — the most important branch of Beijing's Belt and Road Initiative. The surrounding city of Gwadar is also home to some of the CPEC’s most ambitious projects, including a six-lane highway linking the port to the national highway system, and a proposal to build Pakistan’s biggest airport. The port's expansion would lessen China's reliance on the Strait of Malacca by providing an overland trade and energy route connecting the Middle East and Africa with its western Xinjiang province. Gwadar's location could also offer China a military advantage in a potential conflict against India by serving as a naval base — adding to the project's strategic significance.

China's stronger relationship with Pakistan will give it the upper hand over India regarding the speed and scope of Beijing and New Delhi's vying port developments.

Potential Hitches. Secessionist rebels in the Balochistan province have risked stalling development, however. In their ongoing fight to separate from Islamabad's rule, Baloch militants have chosen to target CPEC projects. In May, Baloch militants attacked a luxury hotel in Gwadar that left five people dead — raising Beijing's concerns over the safety of its laborers on the project. For Pakistan, the attack reinforced the need for the 15,000-troop division it has been assembling to guard the CPEC. Pakistan has also long suspected an Indian hand behind the separatists: In 2016, Pakistani authorities arrested an Indian national in Balochistan it accused of spying for Indian intelligence and coordination operations with the separatists. (New Delhi admitted the Indian national served in the Indian navy but denied his involvement in espionage.)

Race to the Finish

Despite these security concerns, China's relationship with Pakistan still remains much stronger than India's relationship with Iran. And it is this fact that will give Beijing the upper hand over New Delhi regarding the speed and scope of their respective port developments. But this, of course, won't keep India from trying to keep up. The expansion of China's Belt and Road Initiative across South Asia will continue to drive India's own regional outreach across the Indian Ocean rimland — fueled by its own quest to expand its global advantage across South Asia. Thus, in the coming years, the importance of the Iranian port will only become even more important for India, as it works to counter China's vying strategy in Pakistan.

Article Search

Copyright © Stratfor Enterprises, LLC. All rights reserved.

Stratfor Worldview

OUR COMMITMENT

To empower members to confidently understand and navigate a continuously changing and complex global environment.

GET THE MOBILE APPGoogle Play