U.S. Tariff Threats Give China All the More Reason to Reform Its Auto Sector

6 MINS READSep 24, 2018 | 09:00 GMT
A Chinese autoworker is pictured on an SUV production line for the BAIC Motor Corp. on Aug. 29, 2018.

A Chinese autoworker is pictured on an SUV production line for the BAIC Motor Corp. on Aug. 29, 2018. China aims to consolidate its automotive sector to make it more competitive. But the road to reform will be long and difficult.

  • Though their focus on domestic demand will largely insulate China's automakers from increased U.S. auto tariffs, the prospective competition as the country opens its market under pressure from Washington will give Beijing more reason to move forward with restructuring the Chinese auto industry.
  • To that end, Beijing will take steps to consolidate the sector to strengthen domestic automakers and reduce overcapacity.
  • Beijing's consolidation campaign, however, will probably face resistance from corporations and local governments concerned with maintaining employment levels.

China's formidable but fragmented auto industry is ripe for a restructuring. As the world's largest auto producer, China now makes more cars than its market can handle. Yet China exports only a tiny fraction of the vehicles it produces, mostly to developing markets such as those in Iran and Vietnam because its cars primarily are lower-end vehicles and, with the exception of electric vehicles, Chinese brands still can't hold their own against the competition overseas. On top of these problems, China is under growing pressure from other countries, including the United States, to open its auto market to foreign brands and investors.

President Xi Jinping announced measures in part to address the U.S. demand, including lowering import tariffs and easing Beijing's 20-year-old restrictions on foreign ownership in the auto industry, in a speech at the Boao Forum in April. A few months later, the Chinese National Development and Reform Commission proposed a plan to correct overcapacity and promote industrial consolidation in the sector. The initiative aims to consolidate the Chinese automotive sector to make it more competitive as the United States pushes for greater access to the domestic market — and drives automakers elsewhere to look for new export destinations under the threat of increased U.S. tariffs. But the road to reform will be long and difficult.

The Big Picture

China is working to gradually open its auto market — just in time for the United States to pressure Beijing for greater market access and threaten higher tariffs on auto imports from its Asian, European and North American allies. The prospect of a more competitive environment under heightened U.S. pressure is pushing Beijing to pick up the pace in its attempts to consolidate the Chinese auto industry in a bid to shore up domestic brands and manage overcapacity.

Too Big to Thrive

Simply put, China's automotive industry is too big for its own good. Domestic consumption is showing signs of slowing after two decades of steady growth; since May, passenger vehicle sales have been down compared with last year. Production, on the other hand, is set to keep rising. The capacity under construction in 2017 could bring China's total annual production to 63.6 million conventional vehicles, more than double the current demand. Similarly, plans to expand electric vehicle manufacturing would put production at 6 million cars per year by 2020 — more than projected yearly sales for electric vehicles worldwide.

A graphic showing China's passenger vehicle market.

The overcapacity in China's automotive sector, like that in its steel or solar panel manufacturing industry, is a long-standing and multifaceted problem. More than in these other sectors, though, protectionist government policies and competing local and corporate interests have contributed to excess production capacity in auto manufacturing. Beijing made the automotive industry a pillar of its plans to industrialize China and to create internationally recognized Chinese brands. To that end, it has long nurtured and sheltered the sector with high tariffs (110 percent in 1994) and caps on imported vehicles. And when foreign automakers flooded in looking for investment opportunities in China, Beijing acceded, with a condition: Foreign companies would have to set up equal partnerships with Chinese automakers, mostly state-owned ones. The joint venture strategy, the central government hoped, would make the most of China's potentially lucrative market while helping local manufacturers to hone their skills and technology.

A graphic showing China's vehicle production and exports.

Diverging Goals

More than two decades later, the plan hasn't worked out quite as intended. The state-owned enterprises are still not competitive in the world market, or even the domestic one — private Chinese automakers such as Geely and Chery far outsell them in China. Most of their profits today come from their joint ventures with foreign companies instead of from their own brands. Meanwhile, Beijing's various protections for the companies — direct subsidies, investment into research and development, and tax incentives — have discouraged rather than fostered innovation. Worse yet for the central government, the joint venture program has united state-owned automakers, their foreign partners and their local governments against its desires to innovate and streamline the supply chain, initiatives that would threaten their interests.

A graphic showing global electric vehicle stock

As China's auto industry has developed, the interests of local governments often have clashed with those of the central government. The priority for local leaders is to promote economic growth and protect jobs in their jurisdictions, even if doing so entails pouring money into subsidies and other programs to support automakers in the area. Some local governments offered electric vehicle manufacturers subsidies that covered the entire cost of production, a practice that enticed hundreds of companies to start producing electric cars. The result is a market in which supply far outpaces demand and a whole class of companies that depend on government support to survive. Though China is home to more automakers than anywhere else in the world — it has an estimated 184 traditional vehicle brands — its top 10 auto companies account for a whopping 87 percent of sales. Six of those firms are joint ventures with foreign companies.


A graphic showing car sales in China, top 10 brands sold in 2017

The Risks of Reform

China's central government has tried to pare down the unwieldy auto industry before, with mixed results. Several prospective mergers fell through because of objections from provincial governments or from the corporations involved, while the number of automakers kept on growing. Today, however, the internal and external factors weighing on the Chinese automotive sector have added new urgency to the reform initiative. The central government already has reduced its tariffs on imported vehicles (excluding those imported from the United States) and has also suggested that it will end its subsidies for electric vehicles by 2020. But the real challenge will be to create a more competitive domestic automotive industry by encouraging manufacturers to move up the value chain and innovate.

Of course, Beijing won't be able to realize its goals for the auto industry overnight. The central government is moving slowly to avoid inflicting too much pain on its domestic automakers at once, as the National Development and Reform Commission's proposal suggests. And even so, the process won't be easy. As Beijing forcibly closes inefficient and unprofitable automakers, workers will lose their jobs and local governments will express their dissatisfaction. Acquiring state-owned automakers, moreover, could undermine innovation at more profitable private companies and hurt their capacity. Finally, the consolidation could worry foreign firms wary of growing competition from China. But for Beijing, the risks of undertaking reform pale in comparison with the risks of failing to do so.

Connected Content

Regions & Countries

Article Search

Copyright © Stratfor Enterprises, LLC. All rights reserved.

Stratfor Worldview


To empower members to confidently understand and navigate a continuously changing and complex global environment.