Why the U.S. Won't Be Leaving Afghanistan Any Time Soon

6 MINS READAug 16, 2016 | 09:15 GMT
Why the U.S. Won't Be Leaving Afghanistan Any Time Soon
An Afghan soldier carries the national flag after government forces took control of a village from the Islamic State in August in Nangarhar province, eastern Afghanistan. The government's losses in other parts of the country outweigh its gains.
Forecast Highlights

  • The Taliban insurgency will continue to threaten the Afghan government's hold on the country.
  • The Islamic State will prove difficult to eradicate in Afghanistan, in spite of the group's weakness there relative to its other areas of operation.
  • Kabul's foreign partners, including the United States, will have a hard time ending their commitments to the beleaguered Afghan government because of these ever-present threats.

Fifteen years after the United States invaded Afghanistan, the country's Taliban insurgency rages on, forcing the embattled Afghan government to continue leaning heavily on foreign assistance. The Taliban's persistent threat to political stability, coupled with the nascent Islamic State menace rising in the east, will make it next to impossible for the United States to extract itself from the Afghan conflict any time soon.

Clear signs of the Taliban's ability to endure emerged as early as December 2014, when the International Security Assistance Force's Afghanistan mission drew to a close. The mission's objective was to shift from counterinsurgency operations to less intensive counterterrorism activities, a drawdown that would be facilitated by an anticipated political deal with the Taliban. But despite lengthy peace negotiations, Afghanistan's insurgency remains as intractable as ever

Last year, the Taliban's traditional summer offensive underscored some of the Afghan government's most worrisome security deficiencies. On Sept. 27, the Taliban seized the northern city of Kunduz, and though Afghan troops recaptured the city with the help of U.S. forces, the insurgents have maintained a presence in the country's north ever since. By 2015's end, the Taliban controlled or had a heavy presence in roughly 30 percent of Afghanistan's districts. Kabul lost its grip on another 5 percent of its territory in the first half of this year. Now, the Taliban hold approximately one-third of the country — more territory than they have had at any point since the United States toppled their government in 2001.

Adopting a New Approach

The intensifying insurgency, along with the peace talks' failure to progress, has forced Washington to reconsider its strategy in Afghanistan. In March, U.S. Gen. John Nicholson became the commander of U.S. Forces Afghanistan and its Resolute Support Mission. Since then, Nicholson has presided over a more proactive strategy that emphasizes offensive strikes against the Taliban, particularly in the east.

On June 9, U.S. President Barack Obama also granted greater military authority to the 9,800 U.S. troops stationed in Afghanistan, allowing soldiers serving in a training and counterterrorism capacity to join conventional Afghan forces on the battlefield if their presence is deemed to have "strategic effect." The move broadens the scope of the airstrike missions supporting U.S. and Afghan troops as well. Moreover, Obama announced in July that the United States will keep 8,400 U.S. soldiers in Afghanistan as the year winds down, rather than reducing their ranks to 5,500 as previously planned.

The renewed forces and operations have already made some gains this summer. Afghan troops, backed by their U.S. counterparts, opened the season by attacking the Taliban in the Maiwand district of Kandahar province. They then shifted their attention eastward to the mountainous region along the Afghanistan-Pakistan border, where they assaulted Islamic State and Taliban fighters in Nangarhar province. The offensives, which received substantial support from U.S. aircraft and special operations forces, have pushed back both groups and have inflicted heavy casualties. (The Islamic State alone is estimated to have lost half of its 3,000 fighters in Afghanistan over the past six months.)

The Government's Losses Outweigh Its Gains

These battlefield victories, however, have been overshadowed by the Taliban's much larger gains elsewhere in the country. Of particular concern to the U.S. and Afghan governments is Helmand province, a strategic southern region that is home to a sizable Pashtun population and a considerable amount of opium. Despite heavy U.S. airstrikes in the area, the Taliban — who already control 80 percent of the region — have steadily encroached on the provincial capital of Lashkar Gah. The insurgents have even reportedly deployed a new commando force equipped with night vision optics and staffed with sharpshooters to facilitate their advance on Helmand.

Meanwhile, the Taliban have also launched offensives across the country to stretch Afghan security forces even thinner, ratcheting up the pressure on Kabul. In doing so, the Taliban are taking advantage of an opening created by the recent changes in U.S. and Afghan strategy: checkpoints. To free up the forces needed for their proactive campaign, Afghan troops have had to weaken and even dismantle many of their checkpoints. This has given Taliban fighters in numerous areas an opportunity to converge on and sever key roads, isolating and coercing the villages caught in the middle into joining them without having to launch costly direct assaults. The Taliban have successfully applied this tactic to several provinces, including Uruzgan and Ghazni.

Even in the east, where the Taliban and Islamic State have long feuded with each other, the two have reached a temporary cease-fire to better focus their efforts on attacking the government. The short-term cessation in hostilities has enabled the Taliban to concentrate on pushing back Afghan troops in Nangarhar province, while the Islamic State has expanded its reach in neighboring Kunar. Perhaps more concerning, though, are the Taliban's attempts to rebuild their presence in the north. The threat the group poses to Afghanistan's crucial ring road, which circles the country, is rising, particularly in Baghlan province, where the Taliban are trying to cut off a portion of the road to restrict Kabul's access to the northern provinces.

Washington's military planners originally expected Afghan troops to be able to hold their own more than a decade after the United States' initial invasion. But with instability still plaguing Afghanistan's north, south and east, they are as dependent on foreign air power and aid as they were when Operation Enduring Freedom began. The United States' withdrawal from Iraq — and the subsequent rise of the Islamic State — serves as a cautionary tale to Afghanistan's foreign partners, though. Fearing a similar outcome, the United States will continue to send the government in Kabul as much help as it needs to stay afloat, even as Washington and its NATO allies grow anxious to shift their attention elsewhere.

Lead Analyst: Omar Lamrani

Connected Content

Regions & Countries

Article Search

Copyright © Stratfor Enterprises, LLC. All rights reserved.

Stratfor Worldview


To empower members to confidently understand and navigate a continuously changing and complex global environment.